The following is a list of all players who have been declared breakout players since its inception. This will assist coaches in determining who is and who is not a breakout player. If you see a player who is on this list then that means that the player has been "broken out" and is not eligible. If you don't see a player on here and they fit the guidelines, then they are eligible. Questions? Email Commissioner. To view a specific year, click on the corresponding year below.
| Team | Player |
| Arizona | Oronde Gadsen |
| Atlanta | Devin Bush |
| Baltimore | Errict Rhett |
| Buffalo | Anthony Harris |
| Carolina | Charles Fisher |
| Chicago | Jason Dunn |
| Cincinnati | Wayne Chrebet |
| Dallas | Olandis Gary |
| Denver | Tory James |
| Detroit | JJ Stokes |
| Green Bay | Tyrone Williams |
| Indianapolis | Stephen Grant |
| Jacksonville | Steve Matthews |
| Kansas City | Peerless Price |
| Miami | Jason Taylor |
| Minnesota | Moe Williams |
| New England | D'Wayne Bates |
| New Orleans | Terrell Fletcher |
| New York(A) | Takeo Spikes |
| New York(N) | Charles Way |
| Oakland | Jay Foreman |
| Philadelphia | Carlos Emmons |
| Pittsburgh | Anthony Simmons |
| San Diego | Richard Huntley |
| San Francisco | Joe Jurivicius |
| Seattle | Edgar Bennett |
| St. Louis | Leonard Little |
| Tampa Bay | Jacquez Green |
| Tennessee | Barron Wortham |
| Washington | Jamel Williams |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Kerry Collins | Tom Knight |
| Atlanta | Antowain Smith | Shaun Williams |
| Baltimore | Chris Coleman | Kim Herring |
| Buffalo | Karim Abdul-Jabbar | Dre Bly |
| Carolina | Troy Davis | Jevon Langford |
| Chicago | Marty Booker | Keith Brooking |
| Cincinnati | Jeff Garcia | Brian Simmons |
| Dallas | Plaxico Burress | Lewis Sanders |
| Denver | Latario Rachal | Eric Hall |
| Detroit | Steve McNair | Shawn Wooden |
| Green Bay | Chris Darkins | Gary Berry |
| Indianapolis | Germaine Crowell | Jeff Burris |
| Jacksonville | James Stewart | Erik Flowers |
| Kansas City | Chris Hetherington | Andre Lott |
| Miami | Edgerrin James | Sam Madison |
| Minnesota | Dennis Northcutt | Brian Gray |
| New England | Na Brown | Chris Canty |
| New Orleans | Danny Wuerffel | Adalius Thomas |
| New York(A) | David Boston | Dexter McCleon |
| New York(N) | Aaron Bailey | Anthony Parker |
| Oakland | Jason Tucker | Corey Fuller |
| Philadelphia | David Patten | Chad Scott |
| Pittsburgh | Kevin Faulk | Kelvin Moore |
| San Diego | Charlie Jones | Anthony Bass |
| San Francisco | Amos Zeroue | Juran Bolden |
| Seattle | Muhsin Muhammad | Dimitrius Underwood |
| St. Louis | Tony Banks | Doug Brown |
| Tampa Bay | Tiki Barber | Dat Nguyen |
| Tennessee | Michael Roan | Travares Tillman |
| Washington | Jerry Porter | Jason Craft |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Thomas Jones | Kevin Abrams |
| Atlanta | Bam Morris | Melvin Johnson |
| Baltimore | Saladin McCullough | Rodney Heath |
| Buffalo | Leon Johnson | Bernardo Harris |
| Carolina | Ricky Williams | Randy Garner |
| Chicago | Reggie Wayne | Hannibal Navies |
| Cincinnati | Cade McNown | Orlando Thomas |
| Dallas | Trent Green | Jimmy Williams |
| Denver | Chris Doering | James Boyd |
| Detroit | Travis Henry | Ryan McNeil |
| Green Bay | Mike Cloud | Alvin McKinley |
| Indianapolis | Kevan Barlow | Kevin Mathis |
| Jacksonville | Kwame Cavil | Andy Katzenmoyer |
| Kansas City | Lamont Jordan | Tony Driver |
| Miami | Travis Taylor | Fernando Bryant |
| Minnesota | Az Hakim | R.W. McQuarters |
| New England | Robert Edwards | Tebucky Jones |
| New Orleans | Chris Weinke | Deon Grant |
| New York(A) | Ron Dugans | Tyrus McCloud |
| New York(N) | Ron Dayne | Duane Starks |
| Oakland | Corey Dillon | Scott Shields |
| Philadelphia | Danny Farmer | Fred Vinson |
| Pittsburgh | Jermane Mayberry | Greg Myers |
| San Diego | Jeff Ogden | Conrad Hamilton |
| San Francisco | Travis Prentice | ? |
| Seattle | Robert Kilow | Jeremiah Pharms |
| St. Louis | J.R. Redmond | Andre Weathers |
| Tampa Bay | Mike Alstott | Kenny Robler |
| Tennessee | Derrick Mason | Pratt Lyons |
| Washington | Ken-Yon Rambo | Junior Ioane |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Bryan Still | Ty Howard |
| Atlanta | Danny Kannell | Jamie Sharper |
| Baltimore | Jerome Pathon | Jamie Henderson |
| Buffalo | Kris Farris | Rogers Beckett |
| Carolina | Shyron Stith | Tremain Mack |
| Chicago | Damon Gibson | N/A |
| Cincinnati | Dan Alexander | Robert Bean |
| Dallas | Correll Buckhalter | Idress Bashir |
| Denver | Chris Cole | DeLawrence Grant |
| Detroit | Ahman Green | Robert Williams |
| Green Bay | Chris Redman | Robert Tate |
| Indianapolis | Darnell Autry | Chris Bayne |
| Jacksonville | DeShawn Foster | Bhawoh Jue |
| Kansas City | N/A | N/A |
| Miami | Chris Chambers | Tony Dixon |
| Minnesota | None | None |
| New England | Calvin Collins | Tom Willis |
| New Orleans | Dadrian Brown | Mike Brown |
| New York(A) | Todd Pinkston | Derrick Gibson |
| New York(N) | Cedric James | Will Peterson |
| Oakland | Damon Jones | Antoine Winfield |
| Philadelphia | Donovan McNabb | Matt Beck |
| Pittsburgh | Tim Dwight | Sam Garnes |
| San Diego | Jay Tant | Keith Bulluck |
| San Francisco | Fred Taylor | John Engleberger |
| Seattle | Ben Hamilton | Harold Blackmon |
| St. Louis | Robert Holcombe | Jacoby Rhinehart |
| Tampa Bay | Nate Jacquet | James Farrior |
| Tennessee | None | None |
| Washington | Albert Connell | Brian Kelly |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Kevin Brown | Tony McCree |
| Atlanta | Curtis Enis | Matt Keneley |
| Baltimore | Jay Graham | David Macklin |
| Buffalo | R. Jay Soward | Patrick Chukwurah |
| Carolina | Joe Montgomery | Warrick Holdman |
| Chicago | Maurice Morris | Clevan Williams |
| Cincinnati | Lamar Gordon | Darren Sharper |
| Dallas | Dominic Rhodes | Paul Tovessi |
| Denver | Shawn King | Darren Howard |
| Detroit | Paul Shields | Daylon McCutcheon |
| Green Bay | Jamal Lewis | Frank Parrish |
| Indianapolis | Alex Bannister | Jason Chorak |
| Jacksonville | Trung Canidate | Chris Howard |
| Kansas City | Brian Finnergan | Darren Hambrick |
| Miami | Tyler Watts* | Jermaine Phillips |
| Minnesota | Tellis Redmond | Al Blades |
| New England | Jake Plummer | Casey Dailey |
| New Orleans | Mike Anderson | Ike Charlton |
| New York(A) | Tim Carter | Ed Reed |
| New York(N) | Najeh Davenport | Brock Williams |
| Oakland | Joey Kent | Lloyd Harrison |
| Philadelphia | O.J. Santiago | Dwayne Goodrich |
| Pittsburgh | Priest Holmes | Michael Booker |
| San Diego | Matthew Hatchette | Ennis Davis |
| San Francisco | Tai Streets | Chike Okeafor* |
| Seattle | Anthony Thomas | Tay Cody |
| St. Louis | Derrick Blaylock | Willie Howard |
| Tampa Bay | James Johnson | Dexter Jackson |
| Tennessee | Freddie Mitchell | Robert Carswell |
| Washington | Darrell Jackson | Will Allen |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Chris Simms | Mike McKenzie |
| Atlanta | Avion Black | Mike Echols |
| Baltimore | Onterrio Smith | Arturo Freeman |
| Buffalo | Deuce McAllister | Eric Barton |
| Carolina | Tony Horne | Ramon Walker |
| Chicago | Kurt Kittner | Thomas Wright |
| Cincinnati | Javon Walker | Terry Cousin |
| Dallas | Jermese Jones | Fred Smoot |
| Denver | N/A | N/A |
| Detroit | Sultan McCullough | Kenny Peterson |
| Green Bay | Jermaine Copeland | William Bartee |
| Indianapolis | Steve Heiden | Eric Joyce |
| Jacksonville | Lee Suggs | Larry Casher |
| Kansas City | Brandon Manemanula | Darwin Walker |
| Miami | Ahmaad Galloway | Lito Sheppard |
| Minnesota | Jamel White | Del Bates |
| New England | Mark Roman | Frank Moreau |
| New Orleans | Kurt Warner | Tony Blevins |
| New York(A) | Woody Dantzler | Anton Palepoi |
| New York(N) | Josh Reed | Terrence Holt |
| Oakland | James Mungro | Rodregis Brooks |
| Philadelphia | Milton Wynn | Hank Poteat |
| Pittsburgh | Robert Ferguson | Adrian Wilson |
| San Diego | Carson Palmer | Wendell Bryant |
| San Francisco | Mike Bush | Chris Cash |
| Seattle | Ladell Betts | Michael Lewis |
| St. Louis | Jeremy Shockey | Anthony Henry |
| Tampa Bay | Sherron Gideon | Kenoy Kennedy |
| Tennessee | Sammy Morris | Matt Stewart |
| Washington | Ennis Haywood | Cory Hall |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Stevonne Smith | Bryan Scott |
| Atlanta | Musa Smith | Sheldon Brown |
| Baltimore | James Williams | Pete Hunter |
| Buffalo | Ronnie Ghent | Edward Prather |
| Carolina | Daunte Culpepper | Antuan Edwards |
| Chicago | Chris Vance | Etric Pruitt |
| Cincinnati | Marcellus Rivers | Rod Coleman |
| Dallas | Tyson Walter | Rashean Mathis |
| Denver | Dallas Clark | Jason Doering |
| Detroit | Willis McGahee | DeWayne White |
| Green Bay | Tommy Banks | Matt Smith |
| Indianapolis | Justin Fargas | Michael Boireau |
| Jacksonville | Lee Mays | Riall Johnson |
| Kansas City | Marvin Minnis | Chris Hovan |
| Miami | Shaun Alexander | Saleem Rasheed |
| Minnesota | Quincy Carter | Mike Rumph |
| New England | Paul Arnold | Terrence McGee |
| New Orleans | Brandon Stokely | Brandon Noble |
| New York(A) | Tyrone Calico | Brandon Everage |
| New York(N) | Rex Grossman | Lance Briggs |
| Oakland | Kelley Washington | Roosevelt Williams |
| Philadelphia | Thunder Collins | Lawrence Flugence |
| Pittsburgh | Luke Staley | Ahmed Plummer |
| San Diego | Andre Davis | Anthony Adams |
| San Francisco | Bryant Johnson | Terence Newman |
| Seattle | Drew Bennett | Derrick Burgess |
| St. Louis | Domanick Davis | Coy Wire |
| Tampa Bay | Aric Morris | Dauntae Finger |
| Tennessee | Drew Brees | Justin Ena |
| Washington | Drew Henson | Jabari Issa |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Billy McMullen | Will Demps |
| Atlanta | Daniel Graham | Markus Steele |
| Baltimore | Jarrett Payton | Dave Johsnon |
| Buffalo | Casey Claussen | Chris Crocker |
| Carolina | Eric Parker | Jason Glenn |
| Chicago | Travelle Wharton | Gerald Hayes |
| Cincinnati | Chad Johnson | Alex Ardley |
| Dallas | Chad Hutchinson | Nick Barnett |
| Denver | Ken Simonton | Will Witherspoon |
| Detroit | Darius Watts | Cedric Henry |
| Green Bay | Chester Taylor | Nick Ferguson |
| Indianapolis | Dwone Hicks | Duane Clemons |
| Jacksonville | Michael Jenkins | Keiwan Ratliff |
| Kansas City | Marcus Pollard | Roderick Babers |
| Miami | Jason McAdderly | JR Reed |
| Minnesota | Herb Haygood | Kris Richard |
| New England | JaJuan Dawson | Daryl Smith |
| New Orleans | Dan Curley | Eli Ward |
| New York(A) | Michael Bennett | Dwight Smith |
| New York(N) | Clinton Portis | Eric Smith |
| Oakland | Greg Jones | Shawn Forte |
| Philadelphia | LaBrandon Toefield | Nick Harper |
| Pittsburgh | James Fenderson | Derrick Strait |
| San Diego | Lee Evans | Dexter Reid |
| San Francisco | Michael Clayton | Lamont Thompson |
| Seattle | Chris Brown | Charles Tillman |
| St. Louis | Josh McCown | Keyon Whiteside |
| Tampa Bay | Jameel Cook | Terrence Carroll |
| Tennessee | Jerramy Stevens | Clifford Smith |
| Washington | Marquise Walker | Anthony Floyd |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Chris Perry | Rich Gardiner |
| Atlanta | Levron Williams | Mike Nattiel |
| Baltimore | Stan Hill | Jeremy LeSueur |
| Buffalo | Artrose Piner | Willie Pyle |
| Carolina | Sean Locklear | Brady Poppinga |
| Chicago | BJ Johnson | Lamont Reid |
| Cincinnati | Johnathan Carter | Scott Fujita |
| Dallas | ReShard Lee | Mike Patterson |
| Denver | Walter Young | Ricky Manning Jr. |
| Detroit | LeVaughn Campbell | Frank Walker |
| Green Bay | Randall Williams | Jamaal Lord |
| Indianapolis | N/A | N/A |
| Jacksonville | Bobby Wade | Alex Lewis |
| Kansas City | Nate Burleson | Jon McGraw |
| Miami | N/A | N/A |
| Minnesota | Donte Stallworth | DeAngelo Hall |
| New England | Moran Norris | Ricardo Colclough |
| New Orleans | Julius Jones | Eric Crouch |
| New York(A) | Ronald Curry | Jeremethius Butler |
| New York(N) | BJ Askew | Jason Shivers |
| Oakland | Cliff Russell | Von Hutchins |
| Philadelphia | Reggie Newhouse | Igor Olshansky |
| Pittsburgh | Jason Johnson | Colin Branch |
| San Diego | Arlen Harris | Rashad Bauman |
| San Francisco | Rod Gardiner | Matt Bowen |
| Seattle | Brandon Lloyd | Andrew Williams |
| St. Louis | Jamaar Taylor | Maurice Jones |
| Tampa Bay | Johnathan Wells | Cory Bird |
| Tennessee | David Kircus | Marcel Almond |
| Washington | Cedric Cobbs | Cato June |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Jon Olinger | Keith Lewis |
| Atlanta | Kevin Curtis | Carlos Hendricks |
| Baltimore | Terrelle Smith | Nick Collins |
| Buffalo | Brandon Drumm | Shurron Pierson |
| Carolina | N/A | N/A |
| Chicago | Steve Terry | Kalimba Edwards |
| Cincinnati | LJ Smith | Kevin Kaesviharn |
| Dallas | Vincent Fuller | Sammie Parker |
| Denver | Reggie Brown | Stuart Schweigert |
| Detroit | Kevin Jones | Bob Sanders |
| Green Bay | Samkon Gado | Greg Taplin |
| Indianapolis | Eric Shelton | Gerome Sapp |
| Jacksonville | Malafou McKenzie | Kentrell Curry |
| Kansas City | Tom Lopienski | Tully Banta-Cain |
| Miami | Triandos Luke | Antowaine Sanders |
| Minnesota | James Lynch | Mike Walker |
| New England | Michael Vick | Julian Battle |
| New Orleans | Larry Johnson | Will Witherspoon |
| New York(A) | Craphonso Thorpe | Kevin Garrett |
| New York(N) | Robert Kent | Chris Clemons |
| Oakland | George Wrightster | Shawn Mayer |
| Philadelphia | Cedric Benson | Albert Means |
| Pittsburgh | Maurice Sikes | Jamaal Branch |
| San Diego | Bennie Joppru | Donald Strickland |
| San Francisco | Ben Watson | Drayton Florence |
| Seattle | Kareem Kelly | DeJuan Groce |
| St. Louis | Cecil Sapp | Terrence Kiel |
| Tampa Bay | James Adkisson | Michael Lehan |
| Tennessee | Sam Aiken | Siddick Shabazz |
| Washington | Gibril Wilson | Santonio Beard |
| Team | Offense | Defense |
| Arizona | Arnaz Battle | Jonas Rutledge |
| Atlanta | JJ Arrington | Donnie Nickey |
| Baltimore | Carlos Francis | Daniel Bullocks |
| Buffalo | James Newsom | Ben Emmanuel |
| Carolina | Cameron Worrell | Walter Reyes |
| Chicago | Jerious Norwood | Derek Pagel |
| Cincinnati | Rudi Johnson | Madieu Williams |
| Dallas | Derek Farmer | Antonio Perkins |
| Denver | Eric Ghiaciuc | Matt Ware |
| Detroit | Don McGee | Patrick Crayton |
| Green Bay | Jason Witten | David Young |
| Indianapolis | Ben Roethlisberger | Amon Arnold |
| Jacksonville | Casey Kramer | Dominique Foxworth |
| Kansas City | Roddy White | Keith Davis |
| Miami | DeMeco Ryans | Lawrence Maroney |
| Minnesota | Devery Henderson | Lewis Moore |
| New England | Maurice Drew | Terrance McGee |
| New Orleans | Anquin Bolden | James Sanders |
| New York(A) | Greg Lewis | Troy Polamalu |
| New York(N) | Jerricho Cotchery | Curtis DeLoach |
| Oakland | JR Russell | Byron Jones |
| Philadelphia | Ernest Wilford | Grant Wiley |
| Pittsburgh | Jason Anderson | Jamal Brimmer |
| San Diego | Ben Troupe | Jason David |
| San Francisco | Thomas Tapeh | Kawika Mitchell |